What's in a Genre?

Diogenes, philosopher and master of sass.

Categorization and naming systems make our lives infinitely easier.  We know when we go grocery shopping that we'll find milk in the section labeled "Dairy" and bananas over in "Produce."  We know that pets from a reptile rescue won't need their hair brushed, and that movies rated "R" aren't ones to take the toddlers to.  But these categorization systems also have serious failings.  Even Plato fell victim to this when, after reiterating Socrates' definition of humans as "featherless bipeds," rival philosopher Diogenes turned up with a plucked chicken and declared "Behold!  A man!" 

The classification of books by genre is a prime example of this.  It would be nightmarish to walk into a bookstore and discover that all books, regardless of their content, were simply arranged alphabetically by author.  In fact, that makes me cringe just imagining it.  But actually breaking them down by category is much easier said than done.

Take Neil Gaiman's American Gods.  Seems straightforward on the face of it, right?  There's supernatural phenomena, so it must be shelved in fantasy.  And indeed, you will find a copy of it there.  But you'll also find copies in our literature section.  Why?  Because it's character-driven magical realism as much as it is a fantastical tale.  What about Mur Lafferty's Six Wakes?  It's a locked-room whodunnit story where everyone's a suspect.  Should be with the mysteries, right?  Nope, that would be shelved in sci-fi, because the locked room is a space ship and all the suspects are clones.

Definitely more psychological thriller than mystery.

Here at Brilliant Books, there are some sections we don't divide out: romance, for example, is shelved with fiction or literature, depending on whether it's plot or character driven.  Then there are sections we've added: psychological fiction is separate from mysteries, because while a police procedural can be tense, that's not necessarily the point of the book, whereas a twisty psychological thriller is designed to keep you guessing from page one.

The point of all this grouping and ungrouping is to make books as accessible and easy to find as possible, both for patrons who are browsing for something new to explore, and for the booksellers who are trying to keep the names, authors, and locations of all these books straight.  While of course we have a computer system that keeps track of everything, it's always best if you can turn around and put your hand on a book rather than having to dash across the store and look it up.

Seriously, don't get me started on steampunk.

But of course there's always something a little unexpected.  When Time Stopped: A Memoir of My Father's War and What Remains is shelved in military history, not memoir.  You'll find Ray Bradbury in both classics and science fiction, but Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go in literature, not sci-fi.  Tales of white collar crime will be over in economics and politics, not on our true crime shelf.  Some Michigan authors are shelved in local, but only if their books deal with local interest topics.  The rest?  Divided out by genre, of course.  Shakespeare's poetry is with his plays, not with poetry.  Canoeing with the Cree is with travel, not history or memoir, and books on houseplants are with interior design, not gardening.  Don't even get me started on steampunk.

Like all classification systems, genres have their uses, and also their limitations.  I've found it's best not to get too hung up on them.  Otherwise, you'll find yourself, like Plato, forced to reconsider your definitions.  Hopefully minus confrontation with a chicken.

Below, I've included some of my favorite genre defying titles.  Can you guess where we've got them shelved?

Staff Pick Badge
This Is Going to Hurt: Secret Diaries of a Medical Resident Cover Image
ISBN: 9780316426725
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Little, Brown Spark - December 3rd, 2019

One of my staff picks, this one is a humorous medical memoir that could also be shelved in political science, since it takes more than a few jabs at the efficiency of Britain's NHS.


Actual location:  Trick question.  It's shelved with our staff favorites!

Afterland Cover Image
ISBN: 9780316267830
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Mulholland Books - July 28th, 2020

A plague wipes out nearly all of the world's male population. One lucky survivor, a young boy, and his mother are trying to get home to South Africa, but the dystopia that America has become in the wake of the disaster is making that nearly impossible.  What do you think?  Sci-fi?  General fiction?


Actual location:  It's shelved as a thriller!

Future Home of the Living God: A Novel Cover Image
ISBN: 9780062694065
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Harper Perennial - November 13th, 2018

Time has started running backward.  Plants are reverting to prehistoric states.  So are animals.  So are humans.  Cedar, who is pregnant and uncertain what world her child will be born into, or indeed what form her child will have, searches for connection with her own biological family while trying to avoid the government organizations that want to take her and her unborn child into custody...for their own protection, of course.


Actual location: literature!

The Warehouse: A Novel Cover Image
ISBN: 9781984823809
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Ballantine Books - August 25th, 2020

In a not-so-distant, not-so-different future, a corporate spy is tasked with invading Cloud, the ubiquitous tech giant that seems bent on dominating every sphere of commerce...and by extension, everything else.  It's a high risk job, but if she can pull it off, it will be worth the reward.


Actual location: Mixed!  When first released in hardcover, it was shelved as a thriller, but now it's found a home in science fiction.

The Wolf and the Watchman: A Novel Cover Image
ISBN: 9781501196782
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Washington Square Press - October 1st, 2019

A Scandinavian historical mystery thriller that could just as easily be shelved in horror.  Though it's technically a staff pick, any idea where it lives when it's not being featured?


Actual location: Literature

The Art of Starving Cover Image
ISBN: 9780062456724
Availability: Backordered
Published: HarperTeen - June 4th, 2019

In small town USA, a gay teenager strives for control through disordered eating, only to discover that starvation gives him superpowers...or perhaps delusions?  The line between is very blurred, and even the reader isn't certain what's real and what isn't.


Acutal location: This is a YA title!  Despite the age of the characters, I was surprised to find this book is billed for young adults.  It's not overly graphic or explicit at all, but the tone and treatment of the story is more nuanced  than is typical of YA.

Staff Pick Badge
Senlin Ascends (The Books of Babel #1) Cover Image
ISBN: 9780316517911
Availability: On Our Shelves Now
Published: Orbit - January 16th, 2018

Okay, I couldn't let steampunk go.  But seriously.  Where should it be shelved?  Fantasy?  Science fiction?  This book is both one of my favorites and a perfect example.  It has it all: an impossible, fantastical building, steam power, airships, pirates, smugglers, (apparent) true love.  But on which shelf should it live?


Actual location: Fantasy...for now.